Author Topic: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?  (Read 2199 times)

Offline AshimotoK0

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 7360
  • Mad Scientist.... more power Igor ! ٩(̾๏̮̮̃̾๏̃̾)۶
    • View Profile
Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« on: June 24, 2020, 08:39:39 AM »
I went to see a bloke recently who sells me parts from time to time  and has Honda classic race machines and most of the remaining original /UK-stocked spares for them.

He told me that a lot of CB450 racers and some owners of standard machines have converted to conventional valve springs, as the torsion bars degrade after 50 odd years in torsion and are hard and expensive to come by NOS. I had never heard of this before  but it seems he is correct.

https://www.caferacer.net/threads/cb450-valve-spring-conversion.11894/
« Last Edit: June 24, 2020, 08:55:59 AM by AshimotoK0 »
“Alright friends, you have seen the heavy groups, now you will see morning maniac music. Believe me, yeah. It’s a new dawn.” Grace Slick, Woodstock '69 .. In the year of the Sandcast.

Online K2-K6

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 5236
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #1 on: June 26, 2020, 02:12:53 PM »
I've been reading through that thread Ash,  but it's like being blasted with a scatter gun of variable quality reasoning  ;D much of it born of misunderstood engineering principles.

The subject is so dispurse because of the above it's hard to make conclusive decisions around it, other sites the posters seem to hold the view that there are no springs in there at all !!

https://www.hondatwins.net/threads/new-or-used-torsion-bars-test-of-6-used-cb450-doch-heads.37856/ looking at this one, I can't visualise just how he's checkng the load (physical arrangement) but the numbers appear repeatable and interesting.
Initial thoughts are that the interpretation of the data,  specifically for B torsion bars, in showing that variance,  are a concern.  But he has no reference of their original (obviously) performance to say that they've changed.  There exists the possibility that the original samples had significant differences straight off the shelf.

The A bars look more like you'd expect from initial metallurgical theory.  Can't be sure of exactly the material used,  but general principle suggests "creep" ( bar loaded continuously without respite) of 0.1% per year,  making  5% from new to now if left under load for entirety.

Have you got facilities to test them?

Would have thought it's possible to reproduce something like this currently,  F 1 routinely use torsion bar in suspension.  Possibly the scale may be within someone's capability to batch produce.




Offline the-chauffeur

  • SOHC Member
  • Posts: 241
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #2 on: July 08, 2020, 12:22:43 AM »

Seems to be fairly common in the 'states in vintage race classes.  Team Hansen is one place to go for spring conversions.  Sounds like they used to do a drop in conversion kit at one time.

There's a bunch of other places that do camshaft regrinds for race 450's, and there's a number of profiles that are accompanied by the warning only to be used with valve spring conversion heads.

Offline AshimotoK0

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 7360
  • Mad Scientist.... more power Igor ! ٩(̾๏̮̮̃̾๏̃̾)۶
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #3 on: July 08, 2020, 08:38:58 AM »

Have you got facilities to test them?


I don't have anything set up yet but I have about 5 sets of torsion bars and I need to select the best set for my engine very soon, so I will have to make something up. From my understanding, the Honda Twins guy merely assembles the torsion bar in the head as normal (the bars are not splined all of the way around the diameter so are effectively 'keyed' in position). He then applies torsion with an accurate  torque wrench until the locating hollow dowel (knock pin) in the head  is in line with the hole in the torsion bar 'arm'. He then notes the torque figure. It must be quite tricky to determine when the dowel in excactly in-line with the hole though because there is only a small amount of angular deflection even on a new torsion bar. So even a small amount of misalignment of the pin relative to the hole will make a big difference to the torque value measured.
“Alright friends, you have seen the heavy groups, now you will see morning maniac music. Believe me, yeah. It’s a new dawn.” Grace Slick, Woodstock '69 .. In the year of the Sandcast.

Online K2-K6

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 5236
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #4 on: July 08, 2020, 08:58:22 AM »
I've not seen their method,  but assumed it was something like you've described.

With the engine/ head held in a jig of sorts,  you could apply effort to the torque wrench with something like a rope loop that you put a "stick" into and twist to keep raising torque level until an able assistant  ;D can slot the pin home.

Or, in the same fashion,  use one of those double ended yacht rigging tensioner to gently wind on more load and hold while you read off torque when pin locates.

Offline AshimotoK0

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 7360
  • Mad Scientist.... more power Igor ! ٩(̾๏̮̮̃̾๏̃̾)۶
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #5 on: July 08, 2020, 09:36:30 AM »
I
Or, in the same fashion,  use one of those double ended yacht rigging tensioner to gently wind on more load and hold while you read off torque when pin locates.

I might do that Nigel (I always knew them as 'turn-buckles'  :)) and put an accurate  tension digital load cell i have,  in line,  to measure the force  and calculate the torque from the length of the bar (bar at 90° to the tensioner).
“Alright friends, you have seen the heavy groups, now you will see morning maniac music. Believe me, yeah. It’s a new dawn.” Grace Slick, Woodstock '69 .. In the year of the Sandcast.

Offline kettle738

  • SOHC Member
  • Posts: 115
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #6 on: July 10, 2020, 07:05:42 PM »

Why would a torsion bar be any more susceptible to ageing than a spring?.....after all, a torsion bar is essentially an unwound spring and twists in exactly the same way.......unless someone knows different?

Mick.   

Online taysidedragon

  • SOHC Master
  • Posts: 1318
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #7 on: July 10, 2020, 07:40:32 PM »

Why would a torsion bar be any more susceptible to ageing than a spring?.....after all, a torsion bar is essentially an unwound spring and twists in exactly the same way.......unless someone knows different?

Mick.   

Coil springs weaken with age too. That's why you measure the spring length.
Gareth

1977 CB400F
1965 T100SS

Offline AshimotoK0

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 7360
  • Mad Scientist.... more power Igor ! ٩(̾๏̮̮̃̾๏̃̾)۶
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #8 on: July 10, 2020, 07:48:15 PM »

Why would a torsion bar be any more susceptible to ageing than a spring?.....after all, a torsion bar is essentially an unwound spring and twists in exactly the same way.......unless someone knows different?

Mick.   

Springs easy to source ... torsion bars NOS, very expensive and NLA from Honda
“Alright friends, you have seen the heavy groups, now you will see morning maniac music. Believe me, yeah. It’s a new dawn.” Grace Slick, Woodstock '69 .. In the year of the Sandcast.

Online K2-K6

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 5236
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #9 on: July 13, 2020, 02:05:11 PM »
There's just such an almost impenetrable fog about these engines in particular that really obscures any clear judgments if they are out there.

It'll be interesting to see what your testing yealds Ash as like you I suspect it's difficult to get a good read of the load while accurately positioned.  If you can get repeatable numbers at least you'll have a more factual foundation to work with.


Why would a torsion bar be any more susceptible to ageing than a spring?.....after all, a torsion bar is essentially an unwound spring and twists in exactly the same way.......unless someone knows different?

Mick.   

As you Mick,  I don't see as much change as is generally put forward by discussion of these components.  Many are projected as nothing more than because it's old,  then it must have changed "stands to reason innit "  ;D out in the great internet.

Metallurgical reasoning gives that steel is prescribed for spring components specifically to alter their long term (permanent) physical composition,  such that defined heat treatment,  hardening,  subsequent stress relieving manufacture,  then leaves the components able to maintain this condition almost indefinitely. 
The metallurgy doesn't change,  all the heat treatment lies way out of engine temperature operating range all reasearched and field tested to levels significantly beyond layman's terms of appreciation or reference.  Many have no hope of understanding it let alone give informed comment,  but that doesn't stop them presenting their "facts".


Offline Bryanj

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 10695
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #10 on: July 13, 2020, 02:16:10 PM »
But when torsion bars are used as suspension on a car they can "settle" over an extended period so there must be some sort of permant twist as it were

Online K2-K6

  • Grogu
  • *
  • Posts: 5236
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #11 on: July 13, 2020, 04:24:42 PM »
But when torsion bars are used as suspension on a car they can "settle" over an extended period so there must be some sort of permant twist as it were

Good point,  I'll elaborate my thinking.

Although we are using "torsion" as overall blanket descriptor,  the material and final process can make a large difference to the component we are discussing.  Other applications I feel aren't the best comparitor as a means of viewing performance of something so specific as the valve springs.

https://www.engineeringenotes.com/metallurgy/steel/heat-treatment-of-spring-steels-metallurgy/26992 this is worth a read if just to demonstrate how intricate are the  choices made by the original design in selecting the most resilient performance.

Offline MrDavo

  • SOHC Master
  • Posts: 1369
  • He who dies with the most toys wins
    • View Profile
Re: Conventional valve springs in a Bomber?
« Reply #12 on: July 13, 2020, 04:33:14 PM »
Porsche 911s sit on torsion bar suspension rather than coil springs, and though I've never heard of it as being a problem, I did notice this on the widely respected Pelican Parts website, however they make a living selling new spares, so do have a vested interest:

Quote
While many normal cars use coil springs, the 911 suspension uses the torsional stiffness of the metal bars in order to provide the necessary spring. Like traditional coil springs, as the cars age the torsion bars have a tendency to become weak, or even snap and break.

My CL450 barn find sat for several decades with an exhaust valve open, causing a mouldy piston crown and a rusty valve seat. However, there have been absolutely zero problems with setting and running that valve, a check after 660 miles showed zero change in the valve clearance.
1969 Honda CL450 'Scrambler'
1974 Kawasaki Z1A
2005 Harley XL1200R Sportster
1985 Porsche 911 3.2 Carrera Sport
1978 VW Bay Window camper van

 

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal