Interesting that there's quite a difference in spring length (preload when installed) which appears to give unwanted lift in control pressure.
It's obviously not the spring that "makes " the pressure, but the system of oil distribution and pump effectiveness. The relief is there ultimately to protect the oil pump drive against hydraulic locking/high pressure. The risk being failure of drive when used against that pressure above designed operating specifications.
Anything that's been worked on to cause high pressure in the system ? Oil present in both sides of the camshaft & valve cover ? Thinking of the oil flow restriction into head here, one on each side.
Oil temperature and viscosity need to be quantified in assessment of the higher pressure, but could be normal for cold engine, hence the factory set point of pressure relief being as it is.
I share your concern, would rather use the original spring in this case. Then check the peak pressure with that, if in specifications then no reason to not use it.