Honda-SOHC

SOHC.co.uk Forums => Project Board => Topic started by: DomP on August 07, 2026, 09:56:50 PM

Title: Where did my thread go?
Post by: DomP on August 07, 2026, 09:56:50 PM
I know it may have caused a few disagreements but there was valuable information in my thread from Ken, Bryan, Nige and Ted regarding mixture screw settings.  If this is how minor disagreements are dealt with I'm not sure this is the form for me, sure lock it but deleting it?!  This has lost some useful information for users.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 07, 2026, 11:30:27 PM
Don’t forget Skoti as well. I predict some of the experts will walk if this carries on, I’ll be one of the first.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: McCabe-Thiele (Ted) on August 08, 2026, 09:44:12 AM
If folk leave then the self appointed Sanitizer has won.

A good friend of mine was a moderator on a Model Building site for many years. He had to deal with the odd trouble maker who would flit from one similar site to another causing discourse. In the end he banned one who tried to rejoin under another name. I don't understand the science, he blocked the users IP address?


Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Athame57 on August 08, 2026, 02:26:44 PM
he blocked the users IP address?

Probably. My friend had a pagan forum I was on, she questioned why two people were using the same computer, she could tell from the IP address. I see no reason why that facility can't be there.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 08, 2026, 04:37:07 PM
Yes, you can do that Ted. The problem is when people share a comp or an internet router. You ban them all, so banning Trigger for instance would most likely ban NJ.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Skoti on August 08, 2026, 05:08:00 PM
Unsurprisingly our administrator decided to cut the tiresome thread.

But on forums such as this perhaps the pen is mightier than the sword and maybe the only way to a final resolution.






 
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Sesman on August 09, 2026, 08:41:59 AM
DOMP. Just a suggestion, but you could start a new thread and schedule out the pertinent “valuable”, factual information. That would be appreciated by all as it would make that information easily accessible?
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 09, 2026, 10:36:15 AM
I know it may have caused a few disagreements but there was valuable information in my thread from Ken, Bryan, Nige and Ted regarding mixture screw settings.  If this is how minor disagreements are dealt with I'm not sure this is the form for me, sure lock it but deleting it?!  This has lost some useful information for users.

Youve done nothing wrong Dom, and tge thread was legitimate in its enquiry.

We can see the background and the division the question has turned up, but its a fundamental part of how these carburettor work, therefore pertinent to setup and running them.

Good overview was offered by different contribution, ultimately to each consensus here between us of just how this works.

Effectively, we've something of a peer group review from those on here from both different experience, different walks of life, independently offering their view. The question was answered with good reasoning and observation, in agreement, of how the flow is managed. I don't believe there was and controversy in that.

Clearly someone saw this as opportunity to exact their own bias and position as self appointed agent to overule anything in the way of further discussion, DR Santizer in this case (not a real doctor) with a whole litany of extreme views as to other's behaviour.
This it what was wrong.

I'll repeat the words I used, because it fully describes his actions. Ignorant of topic and Honda detailed instructions, such  ignorance that he can't even see his mistake and its ramifications. Arrogance in now putting that view and insistence that we should all adhere to that misguided sermon. You really couldn't make this up.

Ted was bang on the money,  indicating correctly that he has supplanted facts with anecdotal and solus experience in dictact of how anyone else should look at this topic.
That doesn't stand up to any reasonable scrutiny, but his actions are then aimed at prevent this being discussed on forum.

This , the setting of these carburettor subsystem are core fundamental part of maintaining these bikes. Making the topic so toxic, with those actions precludes any further realistic discussion with his presence.

DR should have been suspended from from for his actions. He still should if there's to be any pragmatic discussion and with any depth to form and view the operational effects of this function. 

He even suggests putting a pipe up our rear orifice and listening for pops and bangs as alternative to Honda's "incorrect " instructions. Sounds like he's listening to his  own "Farmer Giles " if you get my drift, and that euphemism  ;D

To delete the thread puts a serious mark on this forum's intent. For anyone who's time has been wasted in thinking, writing and editing content, that's not really excusable.

With his actions, he's now put himself in tbe position of others he claims to combat by this path. Specifically, wrong on topic, but denial of and avoiding observable facts in consideration of his very narrow band view.

There's very good reason in why DR is wrong, the disruptive, aggressive approach to now obscure that should not be part of a valued forum.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 09, 2026, 11:19:50 AM
BTW Nige. Your assertion that you can fine tune carb mixture settings by watching for a 100rpm drop etc is 100% correct. I never doubted it myself but of course the DR did. I have recently started to work on my BIL 1976 Z1000A1, I downloaded the workshop manual and guess what, Kawasaki describes what you were saying almost word for word. Maybe you read that in the past and remembered it as Honda instructions. These things happen.

I can post a pic of the method IF anyone doubts it.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 09, 2026, 11:47:36 AM
Pages 72 & 73 of original  750 workshop manual is the method, within overall  carburettor setup.

The 100 rpm drop not present there, it calls for highest rpm when turning airscrew, but added in later Honda manuals.

Thats not a bad addition depending what you experience in idle conditions. That 100 drop away from "peak" many would prefer in how it feel with throttle closed.

It also shows the interaction with absolute vacuum measurement when throttle is closed too, that bit that is often quoted as "it doesn't matter" which partly holds the key to the dreaded "hanging" idle condition dome experience. 

Its not a huge text, but absolutely laden with detail and meaning if approaching with a enquiring mindset.

Worthwhile you putting up the kawasaki reference too Ken.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 09, 2026, 03:04:44 PM
I remember reading the 100rpm drop in a Honda manual but not sure which one, maybe the750/900 dohc
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 09, 2026, 04:11:54 PM
The DR demanded a video as it didn’t believe it.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 09, 2026, 06:05:16 PM
I did have a 750 dohc genuine manual, if its in there i will post it!
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 11, 2026, 10:53:22 AM
RIGHT, just to finalise the setting procedure i have attached pics of 2 pages of CB 750 K manual, ok its a dohc but still a 4 pot with 4 carbs and it describes how to set idle mix using an accurate tacho Ken do you think is acceptable, i could always make it a video by moving the camera about a bit!
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 11, 2026, 10:55:40 AM
Second page was contents and wouldnt upload
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 11, 2026, 11:35:45 AM
Seems pretty self explanatory to me Bryan, of course we’ll get the answer it’s not the same type of carbs etc. You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 11, 2026, 01:19:55 PM
Thanks Bryan, that's very clear to me.

In regard to carburettor type and relevance, this is not conditional to that but to the combustion characteristics of current fuel and the engine being worked on.

In very simple terms (it's using the hardware in place as method of measuring combustion air fuel ratio) uses known combustion effects of A/F ratio to determine complete mix point of burn THEN adds more fuel to that setting to bring down rpm by making the ratio richer. This the same for any carburettor that has a idle control circuit separated from main venturi in providing for accurate low level fueling demand.

That's all it does, nothing else. Its not responsible for part throttle opening response, nor any other characteristics. They have their own means of adjustment.

More involved detail, this is specifically to separate and set the off load /closed throttle air fuel ratio and NOT the initial opening part (under torque loading)  of throttle mixture, which is controlled by the idle jet size.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 11, 2026, 04:11:55 PM
I just knew i had read it in a Honda manual and luckily tripped over the 750KDOHC one whilst looking for some thing else, as usual!
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 12, 2026, 08:41:16 AM
I just knew i had read it in a Honda manual and luckily tripped over the 750KDOHC one whilst looking for some thing else, as usual!

It's interesting the point you made to me recently, that when these bikes were used in 1970s etc, they were and didn't need any real adjustment to this part, they just worked.

I agree with that as constant use, no ethanol, no sitting around for weeks/months etc, nothing changes and they work very well.

Many threads in this are on here are now because in part, or all of the above, along with stripping, clearing, worn components etc, that now needs untangling in chasing a fault in running response on these bikes. Many of these situations simply going further than original manuals could ever envision, making identification of real fault quite involved.

One area I can see, and learnt from forum contribution, is from Skoti in longer term with clear evidence of worn components in main jet and needle. This recently backed up by exvalvsetdabbler and his in depth assessment of this very aspect in his carburettor hardware during rebuild. Quantified assessment of this type are valuable to forum information, particularly in respect to understand whats happened to older components.

The function of that particular area, and seeming to show most wear too, is to all but close main jet flow at low throttle slide position, that in  handing over metering to the low speed circuit. With wear there to compromise that function, it'll be all but impossible to set idle circuit accurately as in effect it has supply of un-metered fuel that distorts the fine resolution metering needed to run at that low level rpm.

Undoubtedly, the original manuals easily facilitated setup when these were ex factory bikes. They are not even complicated to adjust and set.

Given the conditions under which many currently operate though, then the manual can't really go deep enough into the topic to reveal much below that level.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 12, 2026, 10:52:35 AM
Very trus, in all the years i have been doing this i have only ever seen one VISIBLY worn needle and that was on a grey inport Suziki twin of about 400cc from memory and that was ridiculously worn to the point of nearly falling in half, about 1/3 down from top.
Same as in all the 500 i have done i oly ever found one worn crank and again that was so worn it didnt need a mic to say it was scrap!
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 13, 2026, 10:57:41 AM
There's very good advice in those Honda manuals, but takes some additional understanding to fully appreciate certain aspects of the written words.

I refer to them so others can appreciate what was explained by the manufacturer when they made them, specifically to not claim them as my own thoughts, but give full credit to their understanding and foresight when they were published. 

That information was though never intended to go as far as I feel we can delve into them now.

My understanding now, and this changes as variously problems bring up different error and force me into reappraisal of my own experience.

I noted on the deleted thread that 3 key parts exist in how the idle circuit is made to meter fuel for different load scenarios.

#1 The idle jet size. This gives the total/maximum flow of fuel the  circuit is capable of delivering. That is set for peak demand under acceleration load, too little here will flat spot (too lean) before the carburettor moves onto main and needle metering.
#2 The aiscrew and it's position when set through adjustment. This is SOLELY there to give reduction of the potential fuel delivery from #1 above. Specifically, to set the exact air fuel ratio at closed throttle position,  that to give a co reading of 1.0% which should equal 14.2:1 air fuel ratio in combustion.  It has absolutely no load on the motor, only internal friction , heat losses, alternator etc.
More over, it holds the key to stable idle which these were originally renowned for.
It has no function in compensation for any other aspect.

Between these two, running concurrent/concentric whatever way you want to describe it,  they can be set completely separately by change of jet and adjustment of screw. This is vital to understand in how to specify them.

#3 This is the "hidden" function that links the two above (you'll have to go a long way to find description in general working instructions) but gives the translation from idle mixture flow in "ramping" up delivery to ultimate flow of idle jet size in response to throttle slide being opened.  In effect, the sizing of the components along with entry and exit ports, gives a airfuel proportioning function, and that without moving parts.

Overall it allows separately the setting of peak, floor and transition rate of this circuit by understanding how to set them and knowing which part of rpm response is giving a problem in running conditions.

The really clever part of Honda's instruction is that by moving the airscrew it will show you if there's response and by the range the screw us moved, it tell you tge existence of faults by that "measurement" if you know what to look for.
If it doesn't change anything, that would indicate more fundamental fault ultimately to direct the attention toward finding what is wrong to cause that failure.

In essence, this is like an engine check light on a modern vehicle. If that screw shows out of range when trying to get response, it shows the low speed metering or something else (ignition? or leaking intake) is present.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: K2-K6 on August 13, 2026, 02:11:16 PM
With the above detail and understanding, we can use this in a real case to test the data in finding out whether there was false analysis.

Our Dutch co-respondent wrote the technical details of how he made his projection in regard to this topic.

Stating that his bike would not respond correctly in the phase that starts to open the throttle, usually meaning a flatspot from lean running.

He identified, in his solus example, that the airscrew needed to be turned inward during closed throttle idle in eventually bringing the co value from typical of 1% up to the range of 3 ~4% from my recall. This to give correct response to opening the throttle.

If we look at this from the Honda's manual perspective and setting routine, it shows us that the engine needs more fuelling as throttle opens, this is correct. But the method of achieving this he's used is wrong.

What should happen is to give the extra fuel needed by changing the size of the idle jet to a size larger. Then reset the airscrew to give the correct idle mixture metering with throttle closed.

The "fault" he's installed through his action is that he's accepted the error in total peak flow of the idle jet, and then incorrectly used the screw to compensate, which is not its task.
The result is now TWO mixture errors. Too low peak idle jet flow, too high off throttle mixture enrichment. 

What this does is run excessive fuel through the combustion chamber (co target of 3-4% gives something in tbe oder of 12.8~13.1:1 A/F ratio) which is not needed off load, furthermore it's not burnt. This excessive fuelling will go toward washing lubrication from cylinder bore and help in promoting internal  exhaust corrosion effects. It's effectively running it on partial choke continuously.

Changing the size of idle jet first will give the low throttle opening response, along with the higher end of the initial phase leading up to the main jet supply coming on stream.
Airscrew can now set, correctly, the closed throttle mixture, independently, to it's optimum point. There's no need to compromise.

There's further effect too. Notably he's put on forum before about not being able to get a stable low rpm idle with the setup he used. Thats no surprise as running around 12.9:1 ratio at idle will always need more throttle opening to keep some semblance of equilibrium on what is essentially part choked running condition. This resulting in elevated idle rpm.

He doesn't need a video (as demanded) to demonstrate the Honda method, his own evidence in data and setup given on this forum is absolutely proof his assessment is wrong.

That's why his stance should not be taken by us as any way to set up these carburettor for the forum.

I did suggest he came with more conciliatory outlook in tbe deleted thread, that was clearly refused. We could have discussed this at more length to appreciate properly how this system is designed and works, before now.

But he chose to " sanitize" us, the great unwashed on here. He clearly hasn't understood which part of the equipment relates to which problem is experienced.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: deltarider on August 17, 2026, 08:42:49 PM
With the above detail and understanding, we can use this in a real case to test the data in finding out whether there was false analysis.

Our Dutch co-respondent wrote the technical details of how he made his projection in regard to this topic.

Stating that his bike would not respond correctly in the phase that starts to open the throttle, usually meaning a flatspot from lean running.

He identified, in his solus example, that the airscrew needed to be turned inward during closed throttle idle in eventually bringing the co value from typical of 1% up to the range of 3 ~4% from my recall. This to give correct response to opening the throttle.

If we look at this from the Honda's manual perspective and setting routine, it shows us that the engine needs more fuelling as throttle opens, this is correct. But the method of achieving this he's used is wrong.

What should happen is to give the extra fuel needed by changing the size of the idle jet to a size larger. Then reset the airscrew to give the correct idle mixture metering with throttle closed.

The "fault" he's installed through his action is that he's accepted the error in total peak flow of the idle jet, and then incorrectly used the screw to compensate, which is not its task.
The result is now TWO mixture errors. Too low peak idle jet flow, too high off throttle mixture enrichment. 

What this does is run excessive fuel through the combustion chamber (co target of 3-4% gives something in tbe oder of 12.8~13.1:1 A/F ratio) which is not needed off load, furthermore it's not burnt. This excessive fuelling will go toward washing lubrication from cylinder bore and help in promoting internal  exhaust corrosion effects. It's effectively running it on partial choke continuously.

Changing the size of idle jet first will give the low throttle opening response, along with the higher end of the initial phase leading up to the main jet supply coming on stream.
Airscrew can now set, correctly, the closed throttle mixture, independently, to it's optimum point. There's no need to compromise.

There's further effect too. Notably he's put on forum before about not being able to get a stable low rpm idle with the setup he used. Thats no surprise as running around 12.9:1 ratio at idle will always need more throttle opening to keep some semblance of equilibrium on what is essentially part choked running condition. This resulting in elevated idle rpm.

He doesn't need a video (as demanded) to demonstrate the Honda method, his own evidence in data and setup given on this forum is absolutely proof his assessment is wrong.

That's why his stance should not be taken by us as any way to set up these carburettor for the forum.

I did suggest he came with more conciliatory outlook in tbe deleted thread, that was clearly refused. We could have discussed this at more length to appreciate properly how this system is designed and works, before now.

But he chose to " sanitize" us, the great unwashed on here. He clearly hasn't understood which part of the equipment relates to which problem is experienced.
Answer me this. How in the world can I after my succesful readjustment, have arrived at an improved mileage? Before at best 18km to a liter, now 20!
This is often what experts that work with Dyno banks have seen when they have freed bikes from all too strict rules on emissions. They run better and more economical. BTW 4 - 4,5 % CO at idle was not uncommon for that era. Do me a favor. Try to have a CB500 run with 1% CO at idle. Don't make me laugh.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: SteveD CB500K0 on August 18, 2026, 08:16:44 AM
This thread is heading the same way.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 18, 2026, 12:56:37 PM
Steve, is it possible for a member to block and not see a contributers posts? Somehow i doubt it but it would be nice
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Sesman on August 18, 2026, 01:10:34 PM
Who knew that 4 screws could attract so much ‘discussion’. 🫣🥱
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Nurse Julie on August 18, 2026, 01:17:45 PM
Who knew that 4 screws could attract so much ‘discussion’. 🫣🥱
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 18, 2026, 02:51:16 PM
Depends on if they are stainless or brass and countersunk or button
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Laverda Dave on August 18, 2026, 03:49:34 PM
Fuel injection is the way forward, no screws just a laptop with maps🙂
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 18, 2026, 03:52:11 PM
Who knew that 4 screws could attract so much ‘discussion’. 🫣🥱

My 4 screws with the wifes sister prompted much more discussion and far more heated I may add.

Just joking, her sisters ugly.😆😆
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Orcade-Ian on August 18, 2026, 03:55:30 PM
I only remember 2 screws in Porridge, must have missed that episode.

Ian

Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Athame57 on August 18, 2026, 03:56:03 PM
Who knew that 4 screws could attract so much ‘discussion’. 🫣🥱

Show me a jail where they couldn't!  ;D
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Sesman on August 19, 2026, 08:52:36 AM
In answer to Oddjob. We have a phrase in golf for a poor shot that finds its way to the fairway in reasonable order. It’s called a “Sister in law”. It’s up there, but you know it shouldn’t be!
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: SteveD CB500K0 on August 19, 2026, 11:04:24 AM
Steve, is it possible for a member to block and not see a contributers posts? Somehow i doubt it but it would be nice
Go to your profile.
Select “Buddy/Ignore List”
Add or remove members.  Start typing  username and it will give you a dropdown list of names.

You need to do this on a PC. I don’t think there is provision on TapaTalk.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 19, 2026, 02:11:27 PM
Thank you Steve, only time ever wanted.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: McCabe-Thiele (Ted) on August 19, 2026, 02:29:20 PM
I've done it, quite easy.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Oddjob on August 19, 2026, 03:32:14 PM
The problem is you won’t see the crap advice he’s telling other members so you won’t feel obliged to correct it. I did consider it for a while but decided it wasn’t worth it. Saying that, if we all block him he won’t be able to influence anyone as no one can read what he says. I vote for that option.
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: Bryanj on August 19, 2026, 07:33:43 PM
I just dont want to read the crap any more, i am sure Steve would step in if defamation was occuring
Title: Re: Where did my thread go?
Post by: SteveD CB500K0 on August 20, 2026, 10:25:13 AM
When you register, you agree to the terms of use which include:

"you will not post any material which is false, defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing, obscene, profane, sexually oriented, threatening, invasive of a person's privacy, adult material"